This blog is a companion to my recent book, Exploring Data in Engineering, the Sciences, and Medicine, published by Oxford University Press. The blog expands on topics discussed in the book, and the content is heavily example-based, making extensive use of the open-source statistical software package R.

Saturday, February 16, 2013

Finding outliers in numerical data

One of the topics emphasized in Exploring Data in Engineering, the Sciences and Medicine is the damage outliers can do to traditional data characterizations.  Consequently, one of the procedures to be included in the ExploringData package is FindOutliers, described in this post.  Given a vector of numeric values, this procedure supports four different methods for identifying possible outliers.

Before describing these methods, it is important to emphasize two points.  First, the detection of outliers in a sequence of numbers can be approached as a mathematical problem, but the interpretation of these data observations cannot.  That is, mathematical outlier detection procedures implement various rules for identifying points that appear to be anomalous with respect to the nominal behavior of the data, but they cannot explain why these points appear to be anomalous.  The second point is closely related to the first: one possible source of outliers in a data sequence is gross measurement errors or other data quality problems, but other sources of outliers are also possible so it is important to keep an open mind.  The terms “outlier” and “bad data” are not synonymous.  Chapter 7 of Exploring Data briefly describes two examples of outliers whose detection and interpretation led to a Nobel Prize and to a major new industrial product (Teflon, a registered trademark of the DuPont Company).

In the case of a single sequence of numbers, the typical approach to outlier detection is to first determine upper and lower limits on the nominal range of data variation, and then declare any point falling outside this range to be an outlier.  The FindOutliers procedure implements the following methods of computing the upper and lower limits of the nominal data range:

1.                  The ESD identifier, more commonly known as the “three-sigma edit rule,” well known but unreliable;
2.                  The Hampel identifier, a more reliable procedure based on the median and the MADM scale estimate;
3.                  The standard boxplot rule, based on the upper and lower quartiles of the data distribution;
4.                  An adjusted boxplot rule, based on the upper and lower quartiles, along with a robust skewness estimator called the medcouple.

The rest of this post briefly describes these four outlier detection rules and illustrates their application to two real data examples.

Without question, the most popular outlier detection rule is the ESD identifier (an abbreviation for “extreme Studentized deviation”), which declares any point more than t standard deviations from the mean to be an outlier, where the threshold value t is most commonly taken to be 3.  In other words, the nominal range used by this outlier detection procedure is the closed interval:

            [mean – t * SD, mean + t * SD]

where SD is the estimated standard deviation of the data sequence.  Motivation for the threshold choice t = 3 comes from the fact that for normally-distributed data, the probability of observing a value more than three standard deviations from the mean is only about 0.3%.  The problem with this outlier detection procedure is that both the mean and the standard deviation are themselves extremely sensitive to the presence of outliers in the data.  As a consequence, this procedure is likely to miss outliers that are present in the data.  In fact, it can be shown that for a contamination level greater than 10%, this rule fails completely, detecting no outliers at all, no matter how extreme they are (for details, see the discussion in Sec. 3.2.1 of Mining Imperfect Data).

The default option for the FindOutliers procedure is the Hampel identifier, which replaces the mean with the median and the standard deviation with the MAD (or MADM)  scale estimate.  The nominal data range for this outlier detection procedure is:

            [median – t * MAD, median + t * MAD]

As I have discussed in previous posts, the median and the MAD scale are much more resistant to the influence of outliers than the mean and standard deviation.  As a consequence, the Hampel identifier is generally more effective than the ESD identifier, although the Hampel identifier can be too aggressive, declaring too many points as outliers.  For detailed comparisons of the ESD and Hampel identifiers, refer to Sec. 7.5 of Exploring Data or Sec. 3.3 of Mining Imperfect Data.

The third method option for the FindOutliers procedure is the standard boxplot rule, based on the following nominal data range:

            [Q1 – c * IQD, Q3 + c * IQD]

where Q1 and Q3 represent the lower and upper quartiles, respectively, of the data distribution, and IQD = Q3 – Q1 is the interquartile distance, a measure of the spread of the data similar to the standard deviation.  The threshold parameter c is analogous to t in the first two outlier detection rules, and the value most commonly used in this outlier detection rule is c = 1.5.  This outlier detection rule is much less sensitive to the presence of outliers than the ESD identifier, but more sensitive than the Hampel identifier, and, like the Hampel identifier, it can be somewhat too aggressive, declaring nominal data observations to be outliers.  An advantage of the boxplot rule over these two alternatives is that, because it does not depend on an estimate of the “center” of the data (e.g., the mean in the ESD identifier or the median in the Hampel identifier), it is better suited to distributions that are moderately asymmetric.

The fourth method option is an extension of the standard boxplot rule, developed for data distributions that may be strongly asymmetric.  Basically, this procedure modifies the threshold parameter c by an amount that depends on the asymmetry of the distribution, modifying the upper threshold and the lower threshold differently.  Because the standard moment-based skewness estimator is extremely outlier-sensitive (for an illustration of this point, see the discussion in Sec. 7.1.1 of Exploring Data), it is necessary to use an outlier-resistant alternative to assess distributional asymmetry.  The asymmetry measure used here is the medcouple, a robust skewness measure available in the robustbase package in R and that I have discussed in a previous post (Boxplots and Beyond - Part II: Asymmetry ).   An important point about the medcouple is that it can be either positive or negative, depending on the direction of the distributional asymmetry; positive values arise more frequently in practice, but negative values can occur and the sign of the medcouple influences the definition of the asymmetric boxplot rule.  Specifically, for positive values of the medcouple MC, the adjusted boxplot rule’s nominal data range is:

            [Q1 – c * exp(a * MC) * IQD, Q3 + c * exp(b * MC) * IQD ]

while for negative medcouple values, the nominal data range is:

            [Q1 – c * exp(-b * MC) * IQD, Q3 + c * exp(-a * MC) * IQD ]

An important observation here is that for symmetric data distributions, MC should be zero, reducing the adjusted boxplot rule to the standard boxplot rule described above.  As in the standard boxplot rule, the threshold parameter is typically taken as c = 1.5, while the other two parameters are typically taken as a = -4 and b = 3.  In particular, these are the default values for the procedure adjboxStats in the robustbase package.



To illustrate how these outlier detection methods compare, the above pair of plots shows the results of applying all four of them to the makeup flow rate dataset discussed in Exploring Data (Sec. 7.1.2) in connection with the failure of the ESD identifier.  The points in these plots represent approximately 2,500 regularly sampled flow rate measurements from an industrial manufacturing process.  These measurements were taken over a long enough period of time to contain both periods of regular process operation – during which the measurements fluctuate around a value of approximately 400 – and periods when the process was shut down, was being shut down, or was being restarted, during which the measurements exhibit values near zero.  If we wish to characterize normal process operation, these shut down episodes represent outliers, and they correspond to about 20% of the data.  The left-hand plot shows the outlier detection limits for the ESD identifier (lighter, dashed lines) and the Hampel identifier (darker, dotted lines).  As discussed in Exploring Data, the ESD limits are wide enough that they do not detect any outliers in this data sequence, while the Hampel identifier nicely separates the data into normal operating data and outliers that correspond to the shut down episodes.  The right-hand plot shows the analogous results obtained with the standard boxplot method (lighter, dashed lines) and the adjusted boxplot method (darker, dotted lines).  Here, the standard boxplot rule gives results very similar to the Hampel identifier, again nicely separating the dataset into normal operating data and shut down episodes.  Unfortunately, the adjusted boxplot rule does not perform very well here, placing its lower nominal data limit in about the middle of the shut down data and its upper nominal data limit in about the middle of the normal operating data.  The likely cause of this behavior is that the relatively large fraction of lower tail outliers, which introduces a fairly strong negative skewness (the medcouple value for this example is -0.589).



The second example considered here is the industrial pressure data sequence shown in the above figure, in the same format as the previous figure.  This data sequence was discussed in Exploring Data (pp. 326-327) as a troublesome case because the two smallest values in this data sequence – near the right-hand end of the plots – appear to be downward outliers in a sequence with generally positive skewness (here, the medcouple value is 0.162).  As a consequence, neither the ESD identifier nor the Hampel identifier give fully satisfactory performance, in both cases declaring only one of these points as a downward outlier and arguably detecting too many upward outliers.  In fact, because the Hampel identifier is more aggressive here, it actually declares more upward outliers, making its performance worse for this example.  The right-hand plot in the above figure shows the outlier detection limits for the standard boxplot rule (lighter, dashed lines) and the adjusted boxplot rule (darker, dotted lines).  As in the previous example, the limits for the standard boxplot rule are almost the same as those for the Hampel identifier (the darker, dotted lines in the left-hand plot), but here the adjusted boxplot rule gives much better results, identifying both of the visually evident downward outliers and declaring far fewer points as upward outliers.

The primary point of this post has been to describe and demonstrate the outlier detection methods to be included in the FindOutliers procedure in the forthcoming ExploringData R package.  It should be clear from these results that, when it comes to outlier detection, “one size does not fit all” – method matters, and the choice of method requires a comparison of the results obtained by each one.  I have not included the code for the FindOutliers procedure here, but that will be the subject of my next post.

129 comments:

  1. I know it isn't released yet, but are pre-release versions of this package available?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jon - as I indicate at the end of my most recent post, I don't have a pre-release version available yet. Sorry about that.

      Delete
  2. I would love to have a simple explanation of the basis for using 1.5 for identifying outliers when using the boxplot method. This method of identifying outliers is taught to my middle school students and they always ask me, "Why 1.5?" Therefore, I need something simple to explain to them the basis for using this number as opposed to 1 or 2, etc.
    Thanks, Mike

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you for sharing such a valuable article with good information in this blog.learn Data science course with advanced technology.
    Data Science Training in Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  4. myTectra Placement Portal is a Web based portal brings Potentials Employers and myTectra Candidates on a common platform for placement assistance

    ReplyDelete
  5. I like your blog, I read this blog please update more content on python, further check it once at python online training

    ReplyDelete
  6. A befuddling web diary I visit this blog, it's incredibly grand. Strangely, in this present blog's substance made motivation behind fact and sensible. The substance of information is instructive
    Oracle Fusion Financials Online Training
    Oracle Fusion HCM Online Training
    Oracle Fusion SCM Online Training

    ReplyDelete
  7. Beautiful post! This is extraordinarily well explained and describes particularly favorable circumstances for commercial accommodation. I am currently an avid reader of your blogs. Thank you most for the extraordinary assortment, keep writing.
    Thank you and yours!

    DedicatedHosting4u.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks for sharing information
    Yaaron Studios is one of the rapidly growing editing studios in Hyderabad. We are the best Video Editing services in Hyderabad. We provides best graphic works like logo reveals, corporate presentation Etc. And also we gives the best Outdoor/Indoor shoots and Ad Making services.
    video editors studio in hyderabad
    short film editors in hyderabad
    corporate video editing studio in hyderabad
    ad making company in hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nice Information
    "Sanjary Academy provides excellent training for Piping design course. Best Piping Design Training Institute in Hyderabad,
    Telangana. We have offer professional Engineering Course like Piping Design Course,QA / QC Course,document Controller
    course,pressure Vessel Design Course, Welding Inspector Course, Quality Management Course, #Safety officer course."
    Piping Design Course in India­
    Piping Design Course in Hyderabad
    Piping Design Course in Hyderabad
    QA / QC Course
    QA / QC Course in india
    QA / QC Course in Hyderabad
    Document Controller course
    Pressure Vessel Design Course
    Welding Inspector Course
    Quality Management Course
    Quality Management Course in india
    Safety officer course

    ReplyDelete
  10. Good Post
    Yaaron Studios is one of the rapidly growing editing studios in Hyderabad. We are the best Video Editing services in Hyderabad. We provides best graphic works like logo reveals, corporate presentation Etc. And also we gives the best Outdoor/Indoor shoots and Ad Making services.
    Best video editing services in Hyderabad,ameerpet
    Best Graphic Designing services in Hyderabad,ameerpet­
    Best Ad Making services in Hyderabad,ameerpet­

    ReplyDelete
  11. Nice Article
    "Sanjary Academy provides excellent training for Piping design course. Best Piping Design Training Institute in Hyderabad,
    Telangana. We have offer professional Engineering Course like Piping Design Course,QA / QC Course,document Controller
    course,pressure Vessel Design Course, Welding Inspector Course, Quality Management Course, #Safety officer course."
    Piping Design Course in India­
    Piping Design Course in Hyderabad
    Piping Design Course in Hyderabad
    QA / QC Course
    QA / QC Course in india
    QA / QC Course in Hyderabad
    Document Controller course
    Pressure Vessel Design Course
    Welding Inspector Course
    Quality Management Course
    Quality Management Course in india
    Safety officer course

    ReplyDelete
  12. I learned World's Trending Technology from certified experts for free of cost. I got a job in decent Top MNC Company with handsome 14 LPA salary, I have learned the World's Trending Technology from Data science training in btm layout experts who know advanced concepts which can help to solve any type of Real-time issues in the field of Python. Really worth trying Freelance SEO Expert in bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks for this awesome information. If you need an attractive website design for your business, visit OGEN Infosystem and also get SEO Services for your business promotion.
    Website Designing Company

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hey,Thanks for sharing.very interesting.I have bookmarked your blog because very clear information is given.Keep updating more
    big data courses in bangalore with placement

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks for Valuable Information man, IT was Really helpful for me.

    Also, Please reach me for all types of loans - Personal loan at low interest rate in Bangalore

    Trust me Its Really Worth trying for
    Certified Mobile repair center in marathahalli


    ReplyDelete
  17. Thanks for sharing is so amazing and helpful to us.
    Buy Hydrocodone online

    ReplyDelete
  18. Best Article BUY ADDERALL ONLINE Excellent post. I appreciate this site. Stick with it! Because the admin of this web page is working, no doubt very quickly it will be well-known, due to its quality contents.This website was how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally, I’ve found something that helped me.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks a lot for sharing
    Having good health is what most people out there wants but can not achieve. some people takes buy ibogaine online AND buy weed online to get it.

    ReplyDelete

  20. Best Article buy Pain Pills online Excellent post. I appreciate this site. Stick with it! Because the admin of this web page is working, no doubt very quickly it will be well-known, due to its quality contents.This website was how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally, I’ve found something that helped me.
    Best Article buy Roxicodone online Excellent post
    buy Xanax online
    buy Oxycodone online

    Best Article buy Pain Medications online Excellent post. I appreciate this site. Stick with it! Because the admin of this web page is working, no doubt very quickly it will be well-known, due to its quality contents.This website was how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally, I’ve found something that helped me.

    buy Research Chemicals online

    buy Roxicodone online

    buy Cbd Isolate online

    ReplyDelete
  21. The development of artificial intelligence (AI) has propelled more programming architects, information scientists, and different experts to investigate the plausibility of a vocation in machine learning. Notwithstanding, a few newcomers will in general spotlight a lot on hypothesis and insufficient on commonsense application. Machine Learning Final Year Projects In case you will succeed, you have to begin building machine learning projects in the near future.

    Projects assist you with improving your applied ML skills rapidly while allowing you to investigate an intriguing point. Furthermore, you can include projects into your portfolio, making it simpler to get a vocation, discover cool profession openings, and Final Year Project Centers in Chennai even arrange a more significant compensation.


    Data analytics is the study of dissecting crude data so as to make decisions about that data. Data analytics advances and procedures are generally utilized in business ventures to empower associations to settle on progressively Python Training in Chennai educated business choices. In the present worldwide commercial center, it isn't sufficient to assemble data and do the math; you should realize how to apply that data to genuine situations such that will affect conduct. In the program you will initially gain proficiency with the specialized skills, including R and Python dialects most usually utilized in data analytics programming and usage; Python Training in Chennai at that point center around the commonsense application, in view of genuine business issues in a scope of industry segments, for example, wellbeing, promoting and account.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thanks for your effects that you put in for giving very informative and clear post.I always like your posts.Thanks for sharing.Python Programming is king for a majority of ranking metrics.If you need any help in python programming visit our site.
    Python Training Institute In Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
    Replies

    1. Reading on the recent ban on dank vapes have made everyon buy weed online and the FDA looks like they are serious this time around.But with weed for sale online, what makes it so certain that we won't see others online without medical marijuana cards buy marijuana or
      mail order cannabis online. This has created a big confusion in the marijuana dispensaries near me regading the issue of
      marijuana for sale online
      Some good articles on buy weed online or marijuana for sale have been published but the reecent ban on Juul pods and juul pods for sale or juul pods online have created dispair on the population. So what is your take on the recent ban on juul? But the weed for sale industry is gradually taking over. Click here to get some insights on medical marijuana for sale and shrooms for sale online .Dank Vapes

      Delete
    2. The recent decision by the fda to ban juul pods and other juul accessories and juul devices such as juul wraps , juul skins .As matter of fact, not just juul pods where banned, juul flavors such as mango juul pods ,juul mango pods, mint juul pods , mint juul creme brulee juul pods where part of the juul pods flavors banned by the fda before the complete ban on juul came up some few weeks back.But people still search for juul pods for sale , buy juul pods online , mango juul pods for sale , mint juul pods for sale .This has greatly affected the
      buy weed online or marijuana for sale industry since people have seek for refuge in the creme brulee juul pods , creme brulee pods ,
      buy weed online firms now.Girls eager to gain weight have shy away from juul pods and now concentrated on apetamin vitamin syrups.They consume apetamin and apetamin vitamin syrup since they no longer need to norm any part of the body because ketamine or ketamine hcl is in action.

      Delete
  23. Replies

    1. Reading on the recent ban on dank vapes have made everyon buy weed online and the FDA looks like they are serious this time around.But with weed for sale online, what makes it so certain that we won't see others online without medical marijuana cards buy marijuana or
      mail order cannabis online. This has created a big confusion in the marijuana dispensaries near me regading the issue of
      marijuana for sale online
      Some good articles on buy weed online or marijuana for sale have been published but the reecent ban on Juul pods and juul pods for sale or juul pods online have created dispair on the population. So what is your take on the recent ban on juul? But the weed for sale industry is gradually taking over. Click here to get some insights on medical marijuana for sale and shrooms for sale online .Dank Vapes

      Delete
  24. Thanks for sharing is so amazing.
    Buy Hydrocodone online

    Thanks for sharing is so amazing.
    Buy Weed online

    ReplyDelete

  25. Welcome to Scottish Fold Cattery and thanks for your interest click here to Adopt A Scottish Fold Kitten online to our scottish cats and kittens For sale! My name is VERA S. Matt. Me and my husband Owns the small scottish fold farm with the best Scottish fold kitten prices and share my biggest hobby/ Scottish Fold Kittens For Sale cat breeding hence scottish fold Breeders. We breed breeds Scottish Folds. All our Scottish Fold cats have very special Grand Champion blood lines from Europe . We love our cats, they live in the Cattery with us.Scottish Folds are known to be very good natured, affectionate cats who are very human-orientated and become extremely attached to their owners.here Scottish Fold Cats They are easy going and will appreciate the company and cubby holes of any type. They enjoy attention and are not usually shy with strangers. Affectionate without being “pushy”,they make ideal pets and companions.scottish cats and kittens For saleBrowse through our available scottish fold cats and see the Munchkin Scottish folds,Grey Scottish fold kittens,Black scottish fold kittens Since we offer shipping worldwide.Scottish Fold kittens breederKittens For Sale at the catter.Scottish fold kitten prices We also offer Scottish fold kittens near me,Scottish Fold Breeders,Scottish fold Price.
    Buy passport online We are a group of unique experts who manufacture real and fake passports, IDs, buy driver’s licenses and other documents proving your identity or qualification. We have many years of experience in this field that’s why you can be absolutely sure that no matter what you order from us, you will always receive a high-quality document that meets the necessary…buy IELTS certificate online
    Buy passport online
    buy registered documents online

    ReplyDelete
  26. Despite the fact that Adderall is viewed as a physician recommended tranquilize and most patients
    buy adderall online,Buy Adderall Uk & USA on the web or purchase Adderall 30mg from an online drug store, a few patients will in general get dependent on the medication.can you buy adderal online? When it comes to buying fine research chemicals online, quality is the key. buychemstore research chemicals for sale ,LSD for sale,constantly strives at providing you with the continuing evaluation, innovation . We assure you the highest degree of confidence in all of our products not limited to but including cocaine for sale, LSD for sale, heroin for sale, pain medications for sale etc. Here at buychemstore, we pride ourselves on safety.
    buy research chemicals online
    We are a one-stop-shop for the purchase of anabolic steroids.what is anabolic steroids, We are here to make sure you don’t bother about where to buy anabolic steroids from craigslist, eBay, or any other online forums. We are in contract with a large network of pharmacies in North America, Europe and Asia. With our years of experience in the distribution of anabolic-androgenic steroids, we provide top quality services to our clients that cannot be matched by our competitors.This is te best place to Buy legal steroids online, anabolic steroids for sale
    Apetamin vitamin syrup that’s marketed as a weight gain supplement. It was developed by TIL Healthcare PVT, a pharmaceutical company based in India.According to manufacturing labels, 1 teaspoon (5 ml) of Apetamin syrup contains.Apetamin in store,where to buy Apetamin,Is Apetamin syrup Effective in weight gain,buy Apetamin syrup online
    Welcom to our vyvanse online shop where you can buy vyvanse online,Buy vyvanse Uk & USA,learn about vyvanse side effects and have
    vyvanse coupon,vyvanse for sale.
    Buy atorvastatin, sold under the trade name Lipitor among others, is a statin medication used to prevent cardiovascular disease in those at high risk and treat abnormal lipid levels. For the prevention of cardiovascular disease, statins are a first-line treatment. It is taken by mouth.Learn How to use Lipitor, you are free to read about atorvastatin side effects,Buy lipitor UK ,atorvastatin side effects ,
    lipitor for sale. You can also buy juul

    ReplyDelete
  27. Thanks for sharing such informative peice of work ,Welcome to our for Pinball machines ,At pinball machine for sale, we love fixing, customizing and selling all types pinball machine and have been doing it for over 20 years. With all the innovation and new pinball companies starting up, it’s great that we’re in the epicenter of pinball world, Chicago. Pinball machine manufacturers have been forming in Chicago from the earliest days of pinball. That’s probably why we’re able to find great vintage pinballs tor refurbish! Buy pinball machines online such as antique pinball machine,refurbished pinball machines ,stern pinball machine and many more.
    s

    ReplyDelete

  28. Thanks for sharing such informative peice of work ,Welcome to Glock Store ,a Discreet online depot where you can buy firearms and ammunition , Buy guns online ,
    buy ammo discreetly without monotonous deocumentations and ship to your prefered location with no hassle.We are FFL Dealers and stricktly follow the Regulations of the Gun Control Act(GCA).Purchasing Fireamrs and Ammunition online with caution has always been a long process of paperwork because of the inter/Intra state Laws controlling the buying and distribution.At Glock store online shop we cut the Gordian knot and deliver to your location with no hassle.We have a wide range of firearms and ammunition for sale ,buy Ammo such as shotguns,Long guns,Magazines, Optics and accesories which include Century Arms,Kel-Tec,
    Ruger,
    AR15,
    AK47,.Despite the perusal increase in surounding firearms,we issue uncomplicated paths to acquire Firearms for individual and or Family security.If you have ever asked yourself
    how to buy guns and ammunition online with ease and,safety then your question is answered once you are here.All you have to do is choose your firearms, optic, magazine,accessories and add to cart then proceed to check out. READ MORE on how to buy guns and ammunition online discreet.
    Pain management, pain medicine,buy pain medication and buy research chemicals, pain control or algiatry, is a branch of medicine employing an interdisciplinary approach for easing the suffering and improving the quality of life of those living with chronic pain,
    buy lipitor
    You can also buy weed online, buy cbd oil,

    ReplyDelete

  29. WELCOME TO pug puppies BREEDERS HOME BUY A PUG ONLINE|PUG PUPPIES FOR SALE|ADOPT A PUG ONLINE|PUG|BLACK PUG PUPPIES FOR SALE
    We are so glad you stopped by to check out our amazing TEACUP Pug puppies. All of our animals come fully up to date on vaccinations, heart-worm tested negative, and de-wormed, as well as neutered, and treated for any ailments found upon veterinary examination Adopt a teacup Pug puppy
    Ownership of a Pug includes a commitment that is wider in scope than providing doggy necessities and allowing this jovial little pet to occupy a portion of your home. Pug ownership is a give-and-take relationship that will continue throughout the little dog’s life. That enjoyable companionship thrives when each member of the pair respects the other and camaraderie rules the union. Your Pug will entertain you, love you, and be obedient and faithful to you if you spend time with your doggy friend.
    Adopt a pug puppies online puppy onlie or pug puppies for sale online does not all depends on the money involve. You have to love
    Black pug puppies for sale at heart before you go in search of pug puppies for sale or adopt a pug puppy.This means that you have to keep the pug puppy price or cost of a pug puppy or a teacup puppy in mind before you harnest the interest of buying a pug online.

    Welcome to Scottish Fold Cattery and thanks for your interest click here to Adopt A Scottish Fold Kitten online to our scottish cats and kittens For sale! My name is VERA S. Matt. Me and my husband Owns the small scottish fold farm with the best Scottish fold kitten prices and share my biggest hobby/ Scottish Fold Kittens For Sale cat breeding hence scottish fold Breeders. We breed breeds Scottish Folds. All our Scottish Fold cats have very special Grand Champion blood lines from Europe . We love our cats, they live in the Cattery with us.Scottish Folds are known to be very good natured, affectionate cats who are very human-orientated and become extremely attached to their owners.here Scottish Fold Cats They are easy going and will appreciate the company and cubby holes of any type. They enjoy attention and are not usually shy with strangers. Affectionate without being “pushy”,they make ideal pets and companions.scottish cats and kittens For saleBrowse through our available scottish fold cats and see the Munchkin Scottish folds,Grey Scottish fold kittens,Black scottish fold kittens Since we offer shipping worldwide.Scottish Fold kittens breederKittens For Sale at the catter.Scottish fold kitten prices We also offer Scottish fold kittens near me,Scottish Fold Breeders,Scottish fold Price.
    <a

    ReplyDelete

  30. Welcome to Scottish Fold Cattery and thanks for your interest click here to Adopt A Scottish Fold Kitten online to our scottish cats and kittens For sale! My name is VERA S. Matt. Me and my husband Owns the small scottish fold farm with the best Scottish fold kitten prices and share my biggest hobby/ Scottish Fold Kittens For Sale cat breeding hence scottish fold Breeders. We breed breeds Scottish Folds. All our Scottish Fold cats have very special Grand Champion blood lines from Europe . We love our cats, they live in the Cattery with us.Scottish Folds are known to be very good natured, affectionate cats who are very human-orientated and become extremely attached to their owners.here Scottish Fold Cats They are easy going and will appreciate the company and cubby holes of any type. They enjoy attention and are not usually shy with strangers. Affectionate without being “pushy”,they make ideal pets and companions.scottish cats and kittens For saleBrowse through our available scottish fold cats and see the Munchkin Scottish folds,Grey Scottish fold kittens,Black scottish fold kittens Since we offer shipping worldwide.Scottish Fold kittens breederKittens For Sale at the catter.Scottish fold kitten prices We also offer Scottish fold kittens near me,Scottish Fold Breeders,Scottish fold Price.
    Buy passport online We are a group of unique experts who manufacture real and fake passports, IDs, buy driver’s licenses and other documents proving your identity or qualification. We have many years of experience in this field that’s why you can be absolutely sure that no matter what you order from us, you will always receive a high-quality document that meets the necessary…buy IELTS certificate online
    Buy passport online
    buy registered documents online

    WELCOME TO pug puppies BREEDERS HOME BUY A PUG ONLINE|PUG PUPPIES FOR SALE|ADOPT A PUG ONLINE|PUG|BLACK PUG PUPPIES FOR SALE
    We are so glad you stopped by to check out our amazing TEACUP Pug puppies. All of our animals come fully up to date on vaccinations, heart-worm tested negative, and de-wormed, as well as neutered, and treated for any ailments found upon veterinary examination Adopt a teacup Pug puppy
    Ownership of a Pug includes a commitment that is wider in scope than providing doggy necessities and allowing this jovial little pet to occupy a portion of your home. Pug ownership is a give-and-take relationship that will continue throughout the little dog’s life. That enjoyable companionship thrives when each member of the pair respects the other and camaraderie rules the union. Your Pug will entertain you, love you, and be obedient and faithful to you if you spend time with your doggy friend.
    Adopt a pug puppies online puppy onlie or pug puppies for sale online does not all depends on the money involve. You have to love
    Black pug puppies for sale at heart before you go in search of pug puppies for sale or adopt a pug puppy.This means that you have to keep the pug puppy price or cost of a pug puppy or a teacup puppy in mind before you harnest the interest of buying a pug online.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Welcome to Ragdoll Kittens Cattery click here to adopt a ragdoll kitten online We are a small and loving cattery . We are pleased that you have chosen to visit our Ragdoll cats/Ragdoll kittens cattery, and hope you will notice right away from our website how beautiful and loved our Ragdoll cats and kittens are. These beauties are easily integrated into our loving family home, first as mothers carrying the litters, and then from the time the ragdoll kittens are born until they are adopted so we always have Ragdoll kittens for sale|Ragdoll kittens for adoption|Ragdoll kitten price|Ragdolls|Cost of Ragdoll kittens|. Our adult cats have tested negative for HCM and PKD1 through University of California Davis. Upon request, we have five generations of pedigree documentation on our adults available to anyone who is interested. Ragdoll kittens are registered with The International Cat Association (RAGDOLL KITTENS FOR SALE),and are never caged. The cats that are in our reputable breeding program can produce mink, sepia and traditional Ragdoll kittens. Ragdolls have a laid-back personality and enjoy being physically handled making them one of the best lap cats! We are all family here at Ragdoll kittens cattery since we are ragdoll kitten breeders and all the love we bestow by holding each cat and kitten daily further Teacup RAGDOLL Kittens for sale|Hypoallergenic kittens for sale nurtures their loving personalities and temperaments,TICA/CFA REGISTERED RAGDOLL KITTENS FOR SALE thanks for adopting a ragdoll ketten from us

    Welcome to our farm where we breed Registered pomeranian puppies for sale.As a registered pomeranian puppies breeder, we have made it possible for pomeranian puppy lovers to
    buy pomeranian puppies online,buy zwergpitz pomeranian from our family run farm. Pomeranian dogs are small dogs with a weight of 1.36 to 3.17 kg and a withers height of 15 to 18 cm. They are compact but robust dogs with a lush, textured coat and a tall and flat tail. The top coat forms a fur ruff on the neck, for which poms are known, and on the hindquarters they have a margin of feathered hair.You can click HERE to view our available pomeranian puppies

    ReplyDelete
  32. Marijuana—also called weed, herb, pot, grass, bud, ganja, Mary Jane, and a vast number of other slang terms—is a greenish-gray mixture of the dried flowers of Cannabis sativa.

    The main active chemical in marijuana is THC (delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol), the psychoactive ingredient. The highest concentrations of THC are found in the dried flowers, or buds. When marijuana smoke is inhaled, THC rapidly passes from the lungs into the bloodstream and is carried to the brain and other organs throughout the body. THC from the marijuana acts on specific receptors in the brain, called cannabinoid receptors, starting off a chain of cellular reactions that finally lead to the euphoria, or "high" that users experience. Feeling of a relaxed state, euphoria, and an enhanced sensory perception may occur. With higher THC levels in those who are not used to the effects, some people may feel anxious, paranoid, or have a panic attack.
    Cannabis plant used for medical or recreational purposes. The main psychoactive part of cannabis is tetrahydrocannabinol, one of the 483 known compounds in the plant, including at least 65 other cannabinoids. 
    buy real weed online
    how to buy weed online
    buy legal weed online
    buy recreational weed online
    buy weed edibles online
    can i buy weed online
    buy medical weed online
    buy weed online canada
    buying weed online reviews
    buy weed online legit
    buy weed online without medical card
    buy weed seeds online canada
    order marijuana online
    order marijuana seeds online
    how to order marijuana online
    order marijuana online without a medical card
    can you order medical marijuana online
    order marijuana online

    ReplyDelete
  33. I just loved your article on the beginners guide to starting a blog.If somebody take this blog article seriously in their life, he/she can earn his living by doing blogging.thank you for thizs article. python online training

    ReplyDelete
  34. Attend The Machine Learning courses in Bangalore From ExcelR. Practical Machine Learning courses in Bangalore Sessions With Assured Placement Support From Experienced Faculty. ExcelR Offers The Machine Learning courses in Bangalore.
    ExcelR Machine Learning courses in Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  35. Do you know the best cure for Cancer is buy consuming cannabis and talking about consuuming cannbais, it is very disadvantageous to consume cannabis by smoking thats why Vapes have been introduced. The best place to get good vape carts if from

    dank vapes

    dank vapes review

    dank vape

    dank woods


    dank vapes

    mars og

    backwoods


    dank vapes

    blue-glitter-juul-wrap
    cucumber-juul

    juul-basic-kit

    juul-basic-kit-maroon

    ReplyDelete
  36. DMT, LSD, Shrooms and other psychedelics are proving to be a great guide by "supernatural beings". People with weight gain issues can also take the the drug. No need to put a mask over the benefits anymore

    ReplyDelete
  37. medical care is what many people lack in the interior areas of the world. people face a lot of health issues everyday without solution. buy psychedelics online, Buy weed online, Buy cocaine online

    ReplyDelete
  38. Finding a Juul Pods seller is getting more and more difficult as the Juul vape pod becomes more popular. Juul pods and Juul Pod Shops are always in high demand.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Finding a Juul Pods seller is getting more and more difficult as the Juul vape pod becomes more popular. Juul pods and Juul Pod Shops are always in high demand.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Nowadays, getting a doll from a Sex Dolls Shop discreetly has been quite a challenge.
    Big Boobs Sex Dolls for Sale Online is not a common phenomenon in the industry.
    Fantasy and Anime Sex Dolls for Sale are now the official leading trend in the dolls industry. Similar to buying from a
    Discreet Guns Shop

    ReplyDelete
  41. medical care is what many people lack in the interior areas of the world. people face a lot of health issues everyday without solution. buy psychedelics online, Buy weed online, Buy cocaine online

    ReplyDelete
  42. https://tjparrotshome.com/available-parrots/

    ReplyDelete
  43. Do you know the best cure for Cancer is buy consuming cannabis and talking about consuuming cannbais, it is very disadvantageous to consume cannabis by smoking thats why Vapes have been introduced. The best place to get good vape carts if from

    dank vapes

    dank vapes review

    dank vape

    dank woods


    dank vapes

    mars og

    backwoods


    dank vapes

    blue-glitter-juul-wrap
    cucumber-juul

    juul-basic-kit

    juul-basic-kit-maroon


    mango juul

    ReplyDelete
  44. I would like to say that this blog really convinced me to do it! Thanks, very good post.
    Weed for sale online

    ReplyDelete


  45. Juul pods or juul pods near me are becoming the talk of the town.The FDA'S ban on juul pods such as mango juul pods,mint juul pods have slowed down the juul pods for sale businesses in and around the state.Juul pods bulk or juul pods near me are running out of juul pods and thc juul pods, So the mint juul pods or juul mango pods are mostly found in vape stores near me or vape stores who sell cheap vape juice, vape juice, nicotine vape juice or thc vape juice. so vape juice near me or cheap vape juice near me now can be gotten from the vape stores near me other products of the pax era such as pax era pods, pax pods,pax era cbd pods and pax era thc pods are also available in thiese vape shops Juul pods near me ,Juul pods.juul pods bulk mint juul pods,mango juul pods

    ReplyDelete
  46. We are Professional IT technicians and we produce SUPER UNDETECTED COUNTERFEIT MONEY for all currencies and SSD CHEMICALS SOLUTION , fell free to visit our SHOP anytime.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Buy JUUL Pods online today and improve on your smoking habits with our Nicotine JUUL Pods and Vaporizers. Everybody’s JUUL experience is different but nevertheless outstanding. Our brand is among the leaders in Nicotine Vape Cartridges. Order our JUUL Pods and JUUL devices today and become a part of the healthier and safer smoking family.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Thanks for this. We offer you cannabis Online at reduced prices at:
    Quality Weed Store

    ReplyDelete
  49. Medical kush and carts is a high quality Concentrates, Strains, Edibles, Seeds, Tins and more at amazing Prices! We offer a high a wide variety of strains including but not limited to Hybrid, Indica, Sativa, Cannabis Oil, Wax, Edibles, Marijuana Seeds, and Hash.Once the oil in the THC cartridge reaches a certain temperature, it vaporizes. Vaping with a THC Cartridge is more potent than smoking because using a vaporizer reduces the temperature at which cannabinoids change from solid or liquid into gas
    buy medicated marijuana
    banana-kush
    blue-dream
    bubba-kush-2
    cbd-oil
    buy-dank-vape
    gelato
    green-crack-moonrocks
    buy-king-pens-online
    orange-kush
    suzy-q-high-cbd-feminised-seeds
    wedding-cake
    magic-mushrooms-shrooms
    bart-carts
    buy-medicated-edibles-online
    cbd-oil-hemp-additive
    chocolate-bar
    affordable-dank-woods
    girl-scout-cookies-moonrocks
    green-crack-moonrocks
    buy-king-pens-online
    buy-exortic-carts-online
    og-kush-moonrocks

    ReplyDelete

  50. The vaping industry have always been on a varible caused by customers preference through the brand thy find confortable and safe consuming, With juul pods taking over the vape market, vapers with the high zeal to buy juul pods online and other thc vape cartridges frequently search for juul pods near me, cbd juul pods,juul compatible pods buy juul pods online, juul pod flavors, juul pods.A greater proportion of juul vapers have rated juul mango,juul mint and juul menthol as the best juul flavors among others, that not withstanding there are other pods which are juul compatible and refillable with vape juice.Are you loolking for a vape shop near me or near you to buy the best vape juice such as nicotin salts suitable for small devices, pod systems and vape mods?THC cartridges containing cbd vape oil brings you a great vaping experience.Though vaping cbd vape oil also help for canacer,its is the best option to use cbd oil for pain, cbd oil for cancer. To facilitate your online search to buy cbd oil online, search for cbd oil near me.Buying cheap vape juice online is very simple when you serach for vape store near me, vape shop near me.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Jungle boys is an award winning Marijuana brand from Los Angeles. The Jungle boys farm is an authorized and licenced kush grower and distributor.
    Jungle boys also comprise of a jungle boys clothing brand with fabrics such as hoodies, caps, t shirts and sucks.
    The Jungle boys kush strains are wwide spread across both sativa, hybrid and indica species. Jungle boys indica fire brands are usually recommended to patients with medical conditions such as insomnia.
    Jungle boys strains such as the Sin mints, Zack pie ,Jungle mints, Jungle boys,
    Jungle apples , Jungle boys frosted cake , Jungle boys hippy crasher and Motor breath are best sellers of the brand.
    buy Jungle boys online at wholesale prices from the Jungle boys farm.

    ReplyDelete
  52. A good blog always comes-up with new and exciting information and while reading I have feel that this blog is really have all those quality that qualify a blog to be a one.
    i recommend cbd vape juice

    ReplyDelete
  53. Attend The Artificial Intelligence course From ExcelR. Practical Artificial Intelligence course Sessions With Assured Placement Support From Experienced Faculty. ExcelR Offers The Artificial Intelligence course.
    Artificial Intelligence Course

    ReplyDelete
  54. buy weed online at Legit Weed Store

    order your cannabis now at Order Cannabis Meds

    Buy marijuana online at 420 Delivery Store

    Buy medical cannabis online at at Canna Med Shop

    Get your Pill refills at Pill Pharma

    ReplyDelete
  55. Tack Köp legit piller online i sverige på Mundi Apotek

    Tack Köp legit piller online i sverige på Scandinavia Apotek

    Tack Köp legit piller online i sverige på battrehalsa apotek

    Tack Köp legit piller online i sverige på halsovard apotek.

    ReplyDelete
  56. Howdy! bi xêr hatî Buy Dank Vape, li wir hûn dikarin sinifa bilind bibînin vaping hilberên mîna
    exotic dank vapes,
    brass knuckles vapes all from the most trust worthy
    online vape shop.

    ReplyDelete
  57. Thanks for sharing this quality information with us. I really enjoyed reading. Will surely going to share this URL with my friends.
    thc oil cartridges shipped anywhere

    ReplyDelete
  58. Vape carts 4 all specialize in the very finest, pharmaceutical-grade, Organic & Vegan Cannabis and cartridges. We deliver it straight to your home across the globe. Source your medicinal cannabis products with peace of mind, from our all vegan, strictly organic and pesticide-free menu.
    west coast extract vape carts
    krt carts solvent free web site
    krt carts sovent free
    buy krt vape cartridges online
    krt vapes
    krt vape cartridges
    krt dab carts
    curepen
    buy curepen online
    cali gold extract
    buy cali gold extract
    Cali gold carts
    Cali gold extract cartridge 24k
    brass knuckles jack herer
    tahoe og brass knuckles

    ReplyDelete
  59. Swarit Advisors is a performance-driven organization and always aim to provide tailor-made solutions to fulfil every client's business requirement. Swarit's team of experts dedicate themselves in providing the best legal services with their comprehensive understanding of the industry.

    For more details, log on to - https://swaritadvisors.com/

    ReplyDelete